JoeDios.com Forums - View Single Post

mmm, why would anyone give someone a 1 star out of spite? ive saw that written a few times and i dont know what you all mean. is it because someone has given someone a 1 star and then they do it back. i dont think that is the case...i hope its not the case anyway. and still, in my opinion a pic is judged partly on what is in the pic, (and i have a pretty strong art background, be it not in photography, but in pencil, poetry and martial arts, which the form that you have to perfect) the reason i still say this is because creativity has to be part of any art. once again i defend my point of view. say for example, and no this has never been done, someone on here is going to say "but no one does that" this is only a made up example. say i took a pic of a wall, the wall is blue in color with no markings what so ever. no pictures or anything on it. just blue flat surface. my pic is in perfect focus, the lighting is like the gods above have shown on it, would anyone give me 5 stars??? i hope not. and say i painted a smily face on a canvas, the yellow is so perfect that they have now named it the defaut yellow and the eyes are perfectly spaced apart. put my painting next to the mona lisa or something from luis royo and would you still give my oh so perfect smily face a 5??? dont get me wrong for saying this though,i hardly ever rate pics and when i do i think the lowest i have ever given was a 3 and that was because it was very, very blurry. i know someone on here has to give lower ratings, i had a 5 until someone had to give me a one, but im ok with that. and until i am kicked off of here, if i am able to rate and i do not think a pic is perfect enough to rate a 5, i will not, and i should not give it a five in order, i say for the last time, to spare someones feelings. it seems like i am the badguy because i am very opinionated, i have always been like this and i will never change. isnt this partly what this site is about, isnt everything in some way, shape, or form judged on opinion???

02-05-2007, 06:36 AM	#35
lehsreh G.I. Smurf Offline --> Posts: 3,446 --> Join Date: Jan 2006	mmm, why would anyone give someone a 1 star out of spite? ive saw that written a few times and i dont know what you all mean. is it because someone has given someone a 1 star and then they do it back. i dont think that is the case...i hope its not the case anyway. and still, in my opinion a pic is judged partly on what is in the pic, (and i have a pretty strong art background, be it not in photography, but in pencil, poetry and martial arts, which the form that you have to perfect) the reason i still say this is because creativity has to be part of any art. once again i defend my point of view. say for example, and no this has never been done, someone on here is going to say "but no one does that" this is only a made up example. say i took a pic of a wall, the wall is blue in color with no markings what so ever. no pictures or anything on it. just blue flat surface. my pic is in perfect focus, the lighting is like the gods above have shown on it, would anyone give me 5 stars??? i hope not. and say i painted a smily face on a canvas, the yellow is so perfect that they have now named it the defaut yellow and the eyes are perfectly spaced apart. put my painting next to the mona lisa or something from luis royo and would you still give my oh so perfect smily face a 5??? dont get me wrong for saying this though,i hardly ever rate pics and when i do i think the lowest i have ever given was a 3 and that was because it was very, very blurry. i know someone on here has to give lower ratings, i had a 5 until someone had to give me a one, but im ok with that. and until i am kicked off of here, if i am able to rate and i do not think a pic is perfect enough to rate a 5, i will not, and i should not give it a five in order, i say for the last time, to spare someones feelings. it seems like i am the badguy because i am very opinionated, i have always been like this and i will never change. isnt this partly what this site is about, isnt everything in some way, shape, or form judged on opinion???