Converted!
 

Graham, you're going to love this! I have come to realize that I now use new sculpt figures for more of my photos than old sculpt ones, of whom I have always been such a staunch defender. :eek: It's been a gradual conversion, but the awesomely awesome awsomeness (!) of Crosshair, Lowlight, Bludd, Blackout, etc has changed my mind forever. Don't get me wrong, I still have some issues (posability, and the proportions of some), but the really good new sculpt figures are the best figures of all. (Mind you, the bad ones are the worst ever, too!) It also doesn't mean I will ever abandon my faithful old sculpt figures either. This will probably re-ignite the new/old sculpt debate, but what the heck. :)

I go w/ the nu skulpts for other reasons, of course. But the way I see it, when the nu skulpts are right-on, they're better than anything the ARAH did. Yet, when you get the baddest of the baddest of the baddest, well... I like the nu skulpts simply because they are new takes on characters and usually have tighter sculpting involved. I look at the old arah & comic figures and they remind me of little sausages. They have no form, no muscle; everything's tubular. I mean, look at Barrage compared to the v1 Roadblock. Advances in technology, sure, but Barrage is a great example of what Hasbro did right. Crosshair and Bludd too. (I'd use Blackout but he has a weird arm.)

For those who love their ARAH sculpts, more power to them. Those are things that belong in the past for me. I have no desire to revisit the past and the biggest fear is that I'd probably go to BT's and buy everything MOC. Gotta catch 'em all!

While I'm a nu skulpt fan and I do what I can with them, the old era had far more iconic figures, designs, colors and let's face it, a lot of those old designs can't be touched. I have yet to see a decent Tunnel Rat and Falcon yet. I wouldn't say you are converted all the way. I'm willing to bet that if you need a Tunnel Rat or Hawk or Repeater or Falcon or Muskrat, there's only 1 way to go.

Eh, I find reissued RAH appeals to me most these days. Vintage figures seem old and brittle...because they are getting that way.

New sculpts were all over the place, some I like, some I dislike, they almost feel like 3 or 4 different lines. And rumor has it 25th anniversary stuff will go a new direction. Vintage RAH may be the only place to get all the classic character in any consistency for some time to come.

I'm a new sculpt guy, but I can't forget some f the wonderful work that they did with the Comic Pack figures. Some of them are kick asses!!!

You're right of course G, many of the great characters have never been re-sculpted, so there's no choice but to use old sculpts. Just imagine how cool a new sculpt Muskrat would be!! :)

You're too funny. See, I've gotten pretty pessmistic about the new stuff that I don't entirely trust what Hasbro would do. Was it great that Falcon was considered and done, pre-production? Yes, but the choice of parts was horrible. So you say Muskrat or Repeater and I'd worry that H would find a way to screw it up. Ok, you didn't say Repeater. BUT I DID!!! lol

The new Falcon sculpt that was showed is a crap, IMO. And I've to agree with G. I'm affraid about the line even if they will give us someday a wave5 (hahahaha, we don't have the wave 4 yet, hahahaha)

I am an old sculpt kind of guy, mainly because I spent my childhood (late 70's to early 80's) playing with the toys that were out then, the "tail end" of my childhood toys were the first few years of G.I. Joe and they hold fond memories.

When the new sculpt stuff came out, a bunch of people were on one side or the other, I personally was just happy G.I. Joe was going to continue, my big fear when I first heard was that the figures would be larger (like Sgt. Rock), but when I saw them and saw that they were in scale, I was happy.

There are some vintage figures that blow, and some new sculpts that blow, but overall they are all Joes! :) I like them all and have some favorites from both, but like I said, the old sculpt stuff holds a place in my heart from when I was a kid.

--== Paragon ==--

I like both sculpts. Some, like Ranger Viper and Saw Viper, I think are better as new sculpts, while others, like the Cobra Trooper, I prefer the old sculpt, so I won't be getting more of them. For the most part, I try to get new sculpts of characters that I had before, but there are a lot of characters that I like a lot, like Recoil and Falcon (who may or may not get a new sculpt), that don't have new sculpt, so I have to use the old ones.

I think they look fantastic on film. It's like you can be George Lucas or something.






















For those interested in the eternal sculpt war...

History and my vote:

Since I grew up with and collected ARAH JOE as a young lad in 1982-85, I will always appreciate the figures. I don't collect any other toy line. I got a bug for GIJOE in 2004 and my first impulse was Ebay for the vintage ones without any knowledge of the new stuff, or anything. After receiving a couple of ARAH figures I became aware of the other style and at first didn't like them, simply because they didn't conform to the ARAH style. If I was going to start accumulating a collection, I wanted my guys to look the same. Shortly after, I began to really get taken in by the realism of the physical features of the new sculpts. Of course I think they (new sculpts) aren't perfect by any means. I've always been somewhat of a hobbyist, "customizer", "artist" or whatever you want to call it. I find making customs and dio making amazing and really fun. I'm not a toy completist but have acquired a meager collection, don't care much about the figure value or anything, I just love GIJOE and want a selected cast of characters. I think they are represented best in this style.

If done properly, the new sculpt style figures can be similar to mini JOE Marvel Legends with super detail, minus the over-exaggerated proprtions. I also think it's mostly important not to deviate from the fundamental designs of using the O-ring, limbs and parts assembled with screws, etc. Yes, progress is great but don't think super articulation is a good idea. GIJOE yes, Microman nay. It's what makes the figure line unique from another.

Sorry I went off topic quite a bit to bore everyone about myself and political affiliation. ;)

-B